Chicago (2002)
Feb. 26th, 2022 05:04 pmI rewatched the 2002 film of Chicago last night.
- I know every single lyric in this and I was trying to figure out how many times I had to listen to something to pick up the words. Because I saw Chicago on Broadway in 2001 and the movie in 2002, and I’ve listened to the cast album maybe two dozen times? I think this also has both clever lyrics and orchestration that makes them very clear to understand. But still—I don’t think I have to listen to something very much to memorize the words, even without meaning to.
- I know the lyrics of this well enough that I went to see the Takarazuka Revue of it a few years ago, in untranslated Japanese (which I don’t speak). And you know—I don’t think I missed anything.
- I was trying to explain to S (who did not like this much) that the stage version has about a third more songs and a quarter of the characterization.
- The cuts to the songs also made Velma kind of…extraneous? They cut a lot of her songs: My Own Best Friend, I Know a Girl, When Velma Takes the Stand, Class. The choice to make all the musical elements in Roxie’s head also centers her way more. In the show, Velma speaks to the audience at times and comments on what’s going on. The show is more about the rivalry of these two women. So their team up at the end of the movie kind of comes from nowhere. If you don't have My Own Best Friend, how can you pay it off in Nowadays?
- It felt like the movie was trying to be about the trial of Roxie, as if the main conflict was whether she’d be acquitted. I don’t feel like the stage show is really about that? It’s more a commentary on fame and the press. So reframing Roxie’s murder as one where Fred hit her first makes her sympathetic, whereas the show’s murder is totally unsympathetic. Like, every time they tried to make me feel empathy for Roxie in the movie it felt like they were fighting the tone of the show.
- This movie, with Moulin Rouge, set us on the path of modern movie musicals that value actors doing their own singing that led straight to Cats. And none of these singers are particularly great. They do fine, but especially for Richard Gere, he’s compensating for a thin tone by making it more nasal. Why can’t we just dub actors like Bollywood and be fine with that?
- I was reminded of the incredibly shit press attention given to Renee Zellweger’s weight between this and Bridget Jones’s Diary. Like for that movie, they made a big deal of her putting on weight, when she just looks like a normal person. Then a year later she’s in this. If you google Renee Zellweger still you get a ton of photos comparing her size in Chicago to other movies, as if the size she was when doing a dance movie is what she was supposed to always be. It’s so ugh.
- The data compression for streaming REALLY can’t handle falling sequins on the screen. It totally fucks with the key frames.
Overall, this is a good movie, but it’s not my canonical Chicago. I wonder if I went back to it on Broadway, where the 1996 revival still is, if it would have any life left in it. Sometimes when shows run this long, the performances get more than a bit perfunctory.
You know how “Nowadays” has the line, “In fifty years or so/it’s gonna change you know”? That was written in 1975 to reference the gap to when the show was set in 1925. Aaaaaaand now it’s been nearly fifty years since that line was first sung.
- I know every single lyric in this and I was trying to figure out how many times I had to listen to something to pick up the words. Because I saw Chicago on Broadway in 2001 and the movie in 2002, and I’ve listened to the cast album maybe two dozen times? I think this also has both clever lyrics and orchestration that makes them very clear to understand. But still—I don’t think I have to listen to something very much to memorize the words, even without meaning to.
- I know the lyrics of this well enough that I went to see the Takarazuka Revue of it a few years ago, in untranslated Japanese (which I don’t speak). And you know—I don’t think I missed anything.
- I was trying to explain to S (who did not like this much) that the stage version has about a third more songs and a quarter of the characterization.
- The cuts to the songs also made Velma kind of…extraneous? They cut a lot of her songs: My Own Best Friend, I Know a Girl, When Velma Takes the Stand, Class. The choice to make all the musical elements in Roxie’s head also centers her way more. In the show, Velma speaks to the audience at times and comments on what’s going on. The show is more about the rivalry of these two women. So their team up at the end of the movie kind of comes from nowhere. If you don't have My Own Best Friend, how can you pay it off in Nowadays?
- It felt like the movie was trying to be about the trial of Roxie, as if the main conflict was whether she’d be acquitted. I don’t feel like the stage show is really about that? It’s more a commentary on fame and the press. So reframing Roxie’s murder as one where Fred hit her first makes her sympathetic, whereas the show’s murder is totally unsympathetic. Like, every time they tried to make me feel empathy for Roxie in the movie it felt like they were fighting the tone of the show.
- This movie, with Moulin Rouge, set us on the path of modern movie musicals that value actors doing their own singing that led straight to Cats. And none of these singers are particularly great. They do fine, but especially for Richard Gere, he’s compensating for a thin tone by making it more nasal. Why can’t we just dub actors like Bollywood and be fine with that?
- I was reminded of the incredibly shit press attention given to Renee Zellweger’s weight between this and Bridget Jones’s Diary. Like for that movie, they made a big deal of her putting on weight, when she just looks like a normal person. Then a year later she’s in this. If you google Renee Zellweger still you get a ton of photos comparing her size in Chicago to other movies, as if the size she was when doing a dance movie is what she was supposed to always be. It’s so ugh.
- The data compression for streaming REALLY can’t handle falling sequins on the screen. It totally fucks with the key frames.
Overall, this is a good movie, but it’s not my canonical Chicago. I wonder if I went back to it on Broadway, where the 1996 revival still is, if it would have any life left in it. Sometimes when shows run this long, the performances get more than a bit perfunctory.
You know how “Nowadays” has the line, “In fifty years or so/it’s gonna change you know”? That was written in 1975 to reference the gap to when the show was set in 1925. Aaaaaaand now it’s been nearly fifty years since that line was first sung.